WS Winning Coach 7th? It's strange that PS can't reach that power, Rookie wins both league awards

Nov 20, 2024

WS Winning Coach 7th? It's strange that PS can't reach that power, Rookie wins both league awards
L.A. Dodgers manager Dave Roberts answers fans' cheers at the World Series championship event held at Dodger Stadium on the 2nd (Korea time). AFP Yonhap News



WS Winning Coach 7th? It's strange that PS can't reach that power, Rookie wins both league awards
Milwaukee Brewers coach Pat Murphy. AFP Yonhap News
Milwaukee Brewers coach Pat Murphy has been selected as the NL Manager of the Year. The AL Coach Award was won by Cleveland Guardians coach Stephen Boat. This year is the first time that both coaches have led a full-time season.

Murphy received the honor of being the NL's best manager, overwhelmingly beating San Diego Padres manager Mike Shildt (70 points) by scoring 144 points with 27 first-place votes and 3 second-place votes in the BBWAA (National Baseball Journalists Association). Boate had a splendid debut season with 142 seconds, including 27 first-place votes, two second-place votes, and one third-place vote, beating Kansas City Royals coach Matt Quantro (73 points).

However, strictly speaking, Murphy is not a complete rookie head coach. He served as Triple-A manager for San Diego in 2015. He had 96 games as interim manager right after the replacement of Bud Black. However, with 42 wins and 54 losses, he failed to make a clear performance and did not become an official coach.



Murphy moved to Milwaukee in 2016 and began his new leadership career as a bench coach under Crake Counsell. When Counsell was in the baseball team at Notre Dame University, Murphy was the coach. The two, who were teachers and disciples, met again as coaches and bench coaches in Milwaukee.

WS Winning Coach 7th? It's strange that PS can't reach that power, Rookie wins both league awards
Steven Boat, director of Cleveland Guardians. AFP Yonhap News
Counsell led Milwaukee to the postseason five times, including three NL Central wins, in nine years from 2015 to 2023. However, Counsell moved to the head coach of the Chicago Cubs at the end of his contract after last year's season.



The Milwaukee club appointed Murphy as its official manager, and he led the full-time season for the first time this year. The starting environment was not good. Ace Corbin Burns was traded to the Baltimore Orioles, and another mainstay starter Brandon Woodruff underwent surgery on his right shoulder, completely giving up the 2024 season. On top of that, spring trainer Devin Williams was diagnosed with a back injury for four months, promising the second half.

However, Milwaukee continued its fight for No. 1 place in the Central District with four consecutive wins from the start of the season, even in the worst case. Milwaukee has never come down since taking the lead in the Central Division on May 1. Milwaukee, which won the district with a 93-69 record with an overwhelming pennant race, was eliminated by the New York Mets with a 1-2 record in the wild-card series.



However, Murphy is the 13th and 14th full-time rookie coach of the year in history. He was recognized for his ability to command pennant races.

The three NL Coach of the Year finalists were Murphy, Silt, and New York Mets manager Carlos Mendoza.

WS Winning Coach 7th? It's strange that PS can't reach that power, Rookie wins both league awards
The LA Dodgers are a winning team, so even if manager Dave Roberts led them to the postseason for several consecutive years, they will not be given the 'Coach of the Year.' AFP Yonhap News
What is questionable is that LA Dodgers manager Dave Roberts, who is the No. 1 winning percentage in the pennant race by combining the two leagues and won the World Series, finished seventh in the BBWAA vote. Roberts only got three third-place votes. MLB.com Journalist Matthew Ritchie, SB Nation reporter Eric Stephen and St. Louis Post-Dispatch Ben Frederikson each voted third for Roberts.

In common sense, it seems natural that the head coach with the best performance of the year will receive the manager's award, but this year's manager in the Major League is not just looking at the results, but the environment and background are important criteria. Roberts led the winning Dodgers to the postseason for the ninth year since 2016. However, it is rather strange that the Dodgers cannot reach the postseason.

However, Roberts received the 2016 Manager's Award in his first season at the helm of the Dodgers. Since then, he has won many NL West titles and led him to the top of the World Series, but it was far from a coach award.

BBWAA's MVP, Rookie of the Year, Coach of the Year, and Cy Young Award voting will all take place just before the opening of the postseason.



jhno@sportschosun.com